About
  PDF
Full Text
(35 K)

Economic Comparison of Weed Control Systems in Conservation Tillage Systems, AL, AR, CA, GA, LA, MS, SC, & TX

John F. Bradley


 
ABSTRACT

A three to five year study (1998-2002) was initiated by Monsanto to address barriers to Conservation Tillage cotton and develop agronomic systems to maintain or increase yields, lower production cost, and incorporate new technologies, such as, Roundup Ready and Bollgard Cotton. Six Centers of Excellence (COE) were established in locations with low adaptation of conservation tillage systems. Four additional locations were established in 1999. Basic comparisons include three tillage systems: no-till, conservation tillage, and conventional tillage. Each of these tillage comparisons have three herbicide treatments: Roundup Ultra only, Roundup Ultra plus a limited residual, and Roundup Ultra with a full spectrum of residuals.

There were no significant differences in weed control between treatments at any locations. Average cost of weed control treatments range $30/A to $50/A. Tillage cost ranged from $0/A to $35/A . Based on 1998-99 results, residual herbicides are not necessary to obtain excellent weed control with timely application of Roundup Ultra in a Roundup Ready system. No-Till (1998) and Conservation tillage (1999) yields were the highest across locations.

When comparing cost of tillage herbicide systems and herbicide application cost across the COE sites in all three tillage systems, the Roundup Ready system (non-residual) had the lowest cost followed by the limited residual and full residual. Conservation tillage was $20.68/A more expensive than the no-till system. Conventional tillage was $45.08/A more expensive than the no-tillage system.

Cotton growers converting to no-till or conservation tillage should consider and weigh the complementing benefits of non-residuals, less labor, less trips, less equipment, lower repair, and comparable yields for a lower production cost.



Reprinted from Proceedings of the 2000 Beltwide Cotton Conferences pp. 1474 - 1476
©National Cotton Council, Memphis TN

[Main TOC] | [TOC] | [TOC by Section] | [Search] | [Help]
Previous Page [Previous] [Next] Next Page
 
Document last modified Saturday, Jun 17 2000